Topic:
GOVERNMENT
Question: Is George Bush committing or encouraging idolatry with his public statements and actions?
Context: Bush's actions: remarks about Islam, participation in National Cathedral services and the National Day of Prayer, visiting a Shinto shrine.
Thesis: President Bush, although a confessing Christian, is leading the nation astray by his actions.
For starters: he has publicly stated that
Muslims and Christians worship the same God. He has
worshipped at a Shinto shrine in Japan (
more comments and
more). In his
inaugural speech, he referred to the Koran as part of the basis of the character of our nation, along with the Ten Commandments, the Sermon on the Mount, and "the varied faiths of our people."
Please consider the following arguments. Are the incidents reported incorrectly? Are my interpretations incorrect? Should Bush, or any Christian, be rebuked for doing these things?
My Muslim argument is:
A. Bush proclaims Islam to be a way to the one true God.
B. The Bible teaches us that the way to the one true God is through Christ Jesus, who is Himself God.
C. Bush is publicly denying what he claims to believe.
D. Christians should rebuke Bush for false teaching.
---------------------------
My Shinto argument is:
A. Bush performed an act of worship at a Shinto shrine.
B. Both Japanese Christians, the Japanese press, and the Prime Minister of Japan recognize this as an act of worship.
C. The 2nd Commandment forbids this.
D. Japanese and Korean Christians have endured great persecution to avoid this idolatrous Shinto worship.
E. Bush engaged in public idolatry (even if it was only a "little pinch of incense to Caesar")
F. Bush's acts were unnecessary and a great detriment to our Christian brothers in Japan, Korea, etc.